Avoiding the Branding “Bicycle Kick”
Aug 20th, 2008 by Rich Scaglione
It was supposed to be the perfect new business pitch. Years ago, I was part of a team that made a presentation to a major manufacturer of soccer equipment. We put together a thoroughly comprehensive plan — thoughtful research, attention-grabbing ad creative, and a public relations plan that included a barnstorming tour by the national soccer team from Cameroon.
We would arrange for top high school teams from around the country to scrimmage the Cameroonians. The national team would also put on skills demonstrations, including shooting, dribbling and various tricks such as a bicycle kick, where a player kicks the ball in mid-air backwards and over his own head.
We called sports editors at targeted cities, who confirmed that a visit from the Cameroonians would be big news for them, practically guaranteeing coverage. We even created a mock television sports story, featuring a favorite local sports anchor, to show the prospective client what they might expect, as well as demonstrate our strong media connections.
After we proudly concluded our presentation, we asked for feedback. The company’s CEO, a Frenchman and soccer aficionado, had just one comment. He sniffed and said, rather smugly, “You can’t stage a bicycle kick. It is an improvised move on the soccer field.”
And we lost the pitch right there.
Now I could argue here that you can stage a bicycle kick — I have found more than one source on the Web to prove my point. But that’s irrelevant. The only thing that mattered was that, because of a small detail, the CEO didn’t believe we knew enough about his brand. To him, the company represented all things soccer, expert in every nuance of the game.
It actually turned out to be a good lesson. I don’t believe anyone on our team will ever underestimate the importance of thoroughly understanding a client’s brand. That said, clients always know far more about their brands and their businesses than their agencies do. So the trick is to engage clients early and often in the creative process. That will help ensure the work remains consistent with the brand and agreed-upon marketing objectives.
And it’s the best way to avoid a bicycle kick.
————–
About the author: Rich Scaglione, who is a copywriter and account manager at Locomotion Creative, has never even thought of attempting a bicycle kick.












Now that my Vanderbilt teaching is done for the summer, I have some reflections on the year, the students, and what might await them as they move beyond their undergraduate education. My two classes combined for almost 90 students, the vast majority of whom were seniors. Here are my observations from this past academic year.